] ‧₊˚✧[Freshman year/sleepover at Charlotte’s]✧˚₊‧
P.e.r.f.e.c.t, Perfect. That was how Keir’s month was going, she had been quickly accepted into the cheerleading team along with all her friends; Lottie, Lizzy and Camilla, she really couldn’t be happier and she had just came back from her date with Samuel, life was really perfect.
And now.. she was at a sleepover at Lottie’s house. The basement was warm with candlelight, snacks were piled high, and music pulsed low from someone’s playlist, half drowsy, half glitter. They were in pajamas, sprawled on blankets like petals of a flower, all hair masks and lip gloss, the room filled with secrets waiting to be shared. Keir sat to the left of Charlotte, like she always did. There wasn’t a specific reason why she was always at the left, she simply was, after all Lottie was always center and Lizzy right, and that was fine. It was always fine.
“Truth or dare?” Charlotte asked as the bottle landed in front of Keir.
“Uhhhh.. Truth” Keir said as Ava braided her hair, no scrubs by tlc playing in the background.
Lottie frowned, “Boringggg, you always choose truth” She said with a pout, as the rest of the girls giggled and Keir flushed.
“I’ll choose dare next time” Keir promised.
“No you won’t.” Keir didn’t disagree, “But it’s fine, now what should I ask you hmm?” Charlotte placed a finger on her lips, as if she was in deep thoughts. Meanwhile, Keir recited the song that was playing in her head.
So, no, I don’t want your number
*No, I don’t want to give you mine. *
And no, I don’t want to meet you nowhere.
No, I don’t want none of your time
“Okay! I got it now.” Lottie finally spoke “Tell us something you’ve never told anyone.”
Keir frowned, leaning slightly as Ava tightened the braid near her scalp. “That sounds more like a dare.”
The girls broke into laughter. “Just do it,” Lottie giggled, tugging a fuzzy pink pillow into her lap. “We all have something.”
Keir bit her lip, heart flickering with nerves as she thought about it.
The obvious answer throbbed at the front of her mind—Samuel.
Lottie’s brother.
Her boyfriend.
It wasn’t a secret secret, not really. Just something unspoken, something soft and growing, like a secret garden no one had walked into yet. The other girls knew Keir had a boyfriend—she had mentioned she was seeing someone, let them see the smile that bloomed on her face when her phone buzzed—but none of them knew it was him. She wasn’t hiding him(after all he had met her parents and Isaac liked him), they were just private, and didn’t really care to tell the world. Thus, it shouldn’t be a problem for her to say that, but Keir hesitated. After all, it was no secret Samuel and Charlotte didn’t have the best of relationships, at least compared to her and Isaac, and she didn’t want to make things between her and Charlotte. Charlotte was one of her best friends, the reason Keir tried really hard to join the cheerleading team and got in and everyone loved Lottie, how could they not?
And after all, this moment wasn’t about that. This was about her friends. About glitter and sugar and the soft clink of nail polish bottles on a hardwood floor. Not about boyfriends. Lottie tended to be weird about boyfriends.
So she glanced up, smiled a little too long, and said, “Okay… um. When I was in 5th grade, I made myself sick for a week by drinking expired milk because I didn’t want to present my book report.” She hadn’t even told her pastor that.
The room erupted into giggles.
“Keir!” One of their other friends giggled.
“That’s actually disgusting.” Ava wrinkled her nose as she finished the braids.
Lottie gave her a strange look before rolling her eyes. “You are so boring,” Charlotte groaned theatrically, flopping back against the beanbag chair. “I know you wanted to say something else. I could see it on your face.”
Keir only shrugged, offering a sheepish smile. “Guilty.” Lottie nudged Keir’s leg with her foot and passed her a bag of skittles. “Whatever, I still love you.”
Keir smiled down at the rainbow-colored candies now sitting in her lap.
“Love you more.”
Keir leaned back into the pillows, her braid brushing her shoulder, and let herself breathe.
Maybe she’d tell Charlotte one day. When the time was right.
For now, things were still perfect.
Still safe.
Still hers.
A couple of more rounds, and finally the bottle landed on Charlotte. It was Ava’s turn to ask a question and Ava grinned, “Truth or dare?”
“Dare.”
“Okay, Princess Lottie,” Ava teased, using the nickname they all gave Charlotte behind her back and to her face, though she never seemed to mind. “We dare you to tell us who your current crush is.”
Charlotte gave a tight-lipped smile, her head cocked slightly like she hadn’t decided whether to be amused or annoyed. “You guys are so obsessed with me.”
“Because you never say anything!” Ava shot back, throwing a popcorn kernel at her.
“That’s because I don’t have anything to say.” Lottie said, eyes wide, fingers to her chest like she was innocent of all crimes.
The room exploded again.
“Liar!”
“Fake!”
“Literally no one believes you.”
Charlotte groaned and leaned back against Keir dramatically, tossing her arm over her face like a starlet fainting. “Fine, fine, fine! Let me think.”
Keir watched her, eyes narrowed with amused suspicion. Lottie always had a crush. Lottie collected admirers like lip gloss tubes. But her actual feelings? That was harder to read.
Charlotte peeked from under her arm. “Okay. If I had to pick someone…”
Everyone leaned in. Even Lizzy sat upright.
Charlotte smiled sweetly and said, “Tom Welling”
The groans returned in full force.
“Lottie! Be serious!” Ava whined, throwing a stuffed unicorn at her.
Charlotte caught it effortlessly and shrugged, “He’s hot!”
“But it has to be, like a boy in our school.”
Charlotte sighed, finally relenting. “Okay, okay. Fine. Jesse.”
The room froze.
“Jesse?” One of the girls blinked. “Like football jesse?”
“Wait, that actually makes sense.”
“Eeeh! He’s so hot. Why are all the football dudes hot?”
“You two would be so cute together.”
Keir smiled, swallowing the lump in her throat. “Yeah. Totally.” Her voice came out soft, agreeable. Safe.
Charlotte beamed, almost like she’d been waiting for Keir to say that. “Right?” She reached out and plucked a purple Skittle from Keir’s lap, popping it into her mouth. “Maybe one day I’ll actually talk to him.”
Then, a pause.
Her voice dipped just a little softer, silkier, barely above the buzz of the next song loading on the playlist.
“Maybe one day we’ll all go on dates together… when I finally work up the courage. Especially me and you, Keir.”
The words lingered in the air like perfume.
Keir blinked, smile still frozen on her face. She didn’t say anything.
Didn’t have to.
She just smiled.
Soft. Perfect. Like always.
And then the music shifted—
A new song slid in from the speakers, bright and punchy.
Say My Name by Destiny’s Child faded out.
Fergie’s “Glamorous” started.
The mood changed instantly.
“If you ain’t got no money, take yo’ broke—”
A chorus of squeals erupted as the girls reached for invisible microphones, throwing their hands in the air and yelling out the lyrics.
mentioned:
@sunflowerjm - Samuel
@novella - Lizzy
@CerealKiller - Jesse